Oliver walked out of Henderson Hardware into the late May afternoon, a plastic bag in one hand and a crowbar in the other. He wore what he always wore for weekend projects: khaki cargo shorts, a faded Cardinals t-shirt, and the old New Balance sneakers Sarah used to tease him about.
She’d been gone four years now. Emma too. A Thursday in March, on the way to the library.
The sun had finally turned warm after three weeks of rain. Good deck weather. He’d been waiting since March to pry up those rotted boards behind his apartment. Today, he’d finish the job.
His umbrella hung from his wrist by its hook. Sarah gave it to him for their third anniversary, but Emma picked it out. She said her daddy needed a sky to carry when it rained. Its canopy was pale blue, dotted with small white stars. Not once did Oliver feel embarrassed carrying what looked like a child’s umbrella through downtown Des Moines. He brought it everywhere, rain or shine. A habit he’d picked up after the accident. Something to lean on when his knee gave out. Something to hold when his hands needed holding.
The bus stop sat at the far edge of the parking lot, near the Aldi entrance. Oliver walked to the bus shelter, favoring his right leg, the one that had shattered in the accident and healed wrong because he’d spent three months barely moving afterward. The limp was more pronounced today. All that walking around in the hardware store.
A blue Honda Civic was parked three spaces from the bus shelter. He never noticed it. Oliver also didn’t see the woman in the silver SUV watching him from across the lot. He was oblivious most of the time, especially when he wasn’t working on a puzzle. Only the smell of fresh cut grass, the rain still hanging in the air, and the relief of having nothing to do on a Saturday except some manual labor, which he was confident he could handle without any help.
Not a care in the world. Until the police cruiser pulled up to Oliver.
Outside Henderson Hardware, I was parked farthest from the entrance, near the taco truck at the edge of the street, waiting for Oliver. We’d planned to grab lunch, then I’d give him a ride back to his place and help him with the deck. Oliver? He didn’t drive anymore, not since the accident. Unofficially, I was not just his accountant but also his chauffeur. Especially when he needed a pickup truck. Hauling lumber or bags of concrete on DART wasn’t easy.
I was fifteen minutes early. Force of habit. So I sat in my Ford F-150 with my laptop open, reviewing my newest client’s quarterly statements. The weather was beautiful, sunny, and bright, so I rolled down the windows, all while the smell of carne asada drifted into the cab. Forensic accounting? It isn’t glamorous work, but it pays well enough that I can take very long lunches on Saturdays.
I looked up when the automatic doors slid open, and Oliver stepped out, crowbar in hand. He turned left toward the bus stop, and I reached for my phone, texting him, I’m by the taco truck, just as the police cruiser rolled past my bumper, straight toward the front of the hardware store.
The cruiser stopped near the bus shelter, two officers exiting, hands on their holsters. From where I was, I couldn’t hear the interaction, but I watched Oliver put his hands up after he slowly set the crowbar down on the blacktop.
My phone was still in my hand, my message half-typed.
I deleted it, held up my phone and started recording video, watching the officers put Oliver in handcuffs, collect his bag and the crowbar, and put him in the back of their cruiser.
“I just walked out of the store, Officer Jones. I purchased this crowbar. I have the receipt in my pocket,” he pointed to the right side cargo pocket of his shorts. “What’s this all about?”
Oliver answered their questions in a calm voice before asking his own. He knew staying calm was the only thing keeping situations like this from getting worse.
“Mr. Finch,” Officer Jones was reading his identification, “we received a call about a man matching your description attempting to break into vehicles in Henderson’s parking lot.”
“That’s preposterous. What exactly was the description?”
Officer Jones read his notes from a paper spiral notebook. “White male. Medium build. Gray t-shirt. Cargo shorts.”
Oliver looked down, pointed at his Cardinals shirt, his eyes darting back and forth between Officer Jones and his partner, Officer Rodriguez. Red. His shirt had been red for eight years. And faded, at that.
Neither officer said a word. Oliver’s eyes widened. “My shirt? It’s clearly not gray.” He leaned back on his umbrella. “You got the wrong guy, Jones. Rodriguez.”
“The caller said gray,” Rodriguez answered flatly, his hand ready to pull out his pistol.
“Obviously, either you and your partner,” he pointed at Jones, “or the caller was wrong. Now, seeing the evidence before you,” Oliver pointed at his shirt again, “what do you think?”
The younger officer looked at his partner. The partner shook his head slightly.
“Mr. Finch, we’re going to need you to come with us.” Oliver didn’t hesitate to put his hands behind his back as Officer Jones read him his rights.
I watched as Oliver slid into the back of the cruiser, handcuffed. Officer Rodriguez bagged his new crowbar, umbrella, and Oliver’s wallet. Evidence, or so I assumed.
The video lasted four minutes. It showed Oliver standing still, answering questions. Oliver wasn’t resisting arrest, not arguing. He didn’t do one thing wrong, except being a man in the wrong place with the wrong tool in his hand.
I continued watching after I put my phone down as the cruiser pulled out of the parking lot and made a left toward downtown.
Stunned, I sat there for a full minute. My laptop? Forgotten. The line of patrons for the taco truck was growing longer by the minute. I called my sister, Denise.
Denise worked dispatch for the county sheriff’s office, although she sometimes heard what came through city channels. She answered my call on the second ring.
“What’s up, Thomas?”
“Hey, I’m wondering. Did you hear anything about a call at Henderson Hardware? Someone trying to break into cars?”
She popped her gum into the receiver. “Give me just a second, here.” The clicking on her keyboard was rapid, then stopped. “Um, yeah, Thomas. The call came in about what? Twenty minutes ago, it looks like. Anonymous tip. Burner phone, most likely. Untraceable. From my end, anyways. Description says a white male in a gray shirt was trying door handles, holding a crowbar.”
“Denise, they just picked up Oliver outside the hardware store.”
“Finch? Your client, Thomas? Oliver Finch? That’s your Oliver, right? Quirky guy. Carries the umbrella all the time?”
Denise had a way of being direct and airheaded at the same time. She was still popping her gum in my ear. I wondered if that was allowed when she was dispatching the Sheriff. “He wasn’t trying to break into anything, Denise. He walked out of the store, turned toward the bus stop, and stood there. I watched the whole thing. I’ve even got roughly four minutes of video on it.”
She went quiet, but only for a second. “You’re sure?” No gum popping. She sounded what? Nervous?
“I was outside the hardware store, Denise. Waiting for him. We were going to get tacos from the truck in the lot.”
Denise sounded a little panicked. “Thomas, you need to get down there. Now. And bring your video.”
“Why?” I asked her.
“Just do it, Thom. I gotta go.” CLICK.
Inside the interview room, Oliver sat like a statue, his hands flat on the wooden table. The handcuffs were off now; they’d removed them when they brought him inside. The smell of burnt coffee and an industrial bleach-like cleaner burned his nose. His knee throbbed, the fluorescent lights burning his sensitive blue eyes. Five times. Oliver had explained himself five times. And each time the detective nodded, writing something down, and asked again, the same questions, reordered and asked in a variety of ways.
“You tried the handle on the blue Honda Civic?”
Oliver sighed. “I don’t know what a Honda Civic looks like, detective. I haven’t owned a car in four years.”
“You haven’t owned a car in four years. Why not?”
Oliver didn’t answer, but when he thought about the intersection, the one where his Camry got T-boned by the FedEx truck trying to beat the red light? That’s when he flinched, thinking about the car seat that was in the back behind his wife. Emma picked it out herself. It had purple straps. Even after four years, the trauma was fresh.
He didn’t answer the question. “I take the bus now,” Oliver said. “That’s why I was standing at the bus stop.”
The detective leaned back. “Then why, Mr. Finch, would someone call this in?”
Oliver had no answer, but he wanted to spit back because they were mistaken. He thought it over and decided not to answer. Oliver thought about all the times in his life he’d been in the wrong place, looked wrong, matched some description he’d never seen. But mostly he thought about his umbrella. The one they’d taken from him. Sarah gave it to him for their third anniversary. Emma picked it out for her daddy. The handle was worn smooth from all the times he’d gripped it when his knee gave out. After the accident, it wasn’t his knee; it was his heart.
“I’d like to make a call,” he said.
“You’re not under arrest, Mr. Finch.” The detective motioned toward the door. “You are free to leave whenever you want.”
“Then why am I still here?”
The detective studied Oliver’s face. “Because. We’re trying to figure out what happened in the parking lot. And frankly, Mr. Finch. Your story checks out. So far. But I need to be thorough.”
Oliver sighed. “What happened is I bought a crowbar to fix my deck. That’s the whole story, detective. What else do you want from me?”
A knock on the door, then it opened. Another officer leaned in, motioning for the detective. The whisper wasn’t something Oliver could hear. Now the detective’s expression shifted.
“Stay right here,” she said, leaving the room.
“Detective Shaw.” She extended her hand to me, a flat expression on her face. I was standing at the front desk waiting for her. I’d already shown the desk sergeant the four-minute video of Oliver’s arrest. “I understand you have something for me?” I’d been waiting for two hours for her to come out, thanks to the sergeant. I think he did it on purpose.
I replayed the video for her.
“And you recorded this?” Shaw asked. She watched Oliver walking out of the store. Oliver, turning left. Oliver, standing at the bus stop, checking his phone, shifting the bag to his other hand. Then the cruiser pulled in. The whole thing, start to finish. The audio picked up the taco truck’s music, not the interaction between Oliver and the police.
“Yes. I was waiting for Oliver outside.”
“Why not pick him up when he came out?”
“I was working.”
“On what?” Shaw asked.
“Spreadsheets for a client.”
“You know him?”
“Yes. For four years now. I’m Oliver Finch’s accountant.”
The detective asked me to replay the video. Oliver never moved toward any of the parked cars. Never so much as looked at them. He didn’t do anything. Except wait for a bus that never came.
“The caller said he was trying door handles,” she said under her breath.
“Well, your caller lied.”
She stared at me, doing her best to look through me. “That’s a mighty strong accusation.”
“It’s the truth. I watched Oliver walk fifty feet in a straight line from the store to the bus stop. He didn’t slow down. He never stopped. Oliver doesn’t detour. And I assure you, he didn’t touch anything except his shopping bag.” I pointed at the screen. “It’s all right here. You can see it yourself. I even have the timestamp.”
“Sir, come with me.” It wasn’t a request.
An hour later, I was waiting in Shaw’s office.
“They pulled the security footage,” she said to me. “It matches your video.”
Shaw told me the camera over Henderson Hardware’s entrance showed Oliver exiting at 1:47 PM. He turned left. Walked along the sidewalk. Stopped at the bus shelter and stood there. Never moved toward any vehicle.
The camera over the Aldi entrance showed the same thing, only from a different angle.
“The blue Civic belonged to a woman named Patricia Denton. When we called her, she said nothing was missing. Nothing had been tampered with. She hadn’t known about the anonymous tip.”
Shaw leaned back in her chair. “Someone called this in on purpose. Anonymous tip. Burner phone. Description that was close but not quite right.” She looked at me. “Any idea who would do something like that to your client?”
I shook my head. “Oliver doesn’t have enemies. He barely has friends.”
“Everybody has somebody who doesn’t like them.”
“Not Oliver. He’s a widower. Keeps to himself. Solves puzzles. Fixes things.” I paused. “He’s the last person anyone would want to frame.”
Shaw studied me for a moment. “That’s exactly the kind of person someone would frame, Mr…?”
“Thomas. Just Thomas.”
“Well, Just Thomas, your friend, is free to go.”
Oliver walked out of the station at 6:15 PM. The sky was soft, golden-orange. It’s the kind of late spring evening that made people want to sit on porches and watch the light fade and drink icy lemonade.
I stood outside my truck.
“You recorded it,” Oliver said. It wasn’t a question. Shaw told him.
“I was texting you when they pulled in. Video seemed the smarter choice.”
Oliver stood there for a moment, processing. “But you saw the whole thing. You watched.”
“From the minute you walked out of the store, Oliver.”
He shook his head slowly. “Thomas. If you hadn’t been there. At that exact moment.”
“But I was, Oliver.”
“If you’d been late.”
I smiled. “Oliver.” I opened the passenger door. “Get in. We missed lunch. I’m buying you dinner.”
He climbed into the truck, wincing as he bent his bad knee. Through the windshield, streetlights were starting to flicker on.
“Someone did this on purpose,” he said. “Someone called that in, knowing full well it wasn’t true.”
“You have enemies?”
“Not that I know of. I don’t have anyone who would want to do this.” He watched the hardware store disappear in the side mirror. “That’s what I can’t figure out. Who’d care enough to do something like that to me?”
I pulled onto Oak Street. The taco truck was long closed, so I headed to the diner on Fifth.
“The crowbar’s in evidence,” Oliver sighed. “They said I can pick it up next week. My umbrella too.” He fingered the window. “It’s supposed to rain next week, Thomas.”
“I’ve got a crowbar you can borrow,” I smiled.
Oliver wasn’t listening. “That umbrella. It was a gift. From Sarah. Our third anniversary. Emma picked it out.” His voice caught on his daughter’s name. “She said I needed a sky to carry.”
I didn’t utter a sound. There was nothing to say about a man’s dead wife’s anniversary gift sitting in an evidence locker because someone made a phone call.
Oliver hummed, almost without realizing it. Emma’s song. The one about the moon and the boat. The one he’d sung to her every night for five years until that Thursday in March.
I didn’t comment. You don’t comment on grief when it’s sitting next to you.
“Thank you,” Oliver said, breaking the silence.
“For what?”
“For paying attention. For being fifteen minutes early.” He almost smiled. “For not just texting me and looking back down at your laptop.”
I thought about how close it had been. If I’d arrived on time instead of early. If I’d been focused on my spreadsheets instead of looking up. If I’d sent that text and missed the whole thing.
“That’s what you do,” I said.
“What?”
“You show up. You pay attention. You tell the truth about what you see.”
Oliver was quiet for a moment. Then: “She would’ve been nine this summer. Emma. She wanted a purple bicycle with rainbow streamers. And a horn.”
The diner’s neon sign glowed. OPEN 24 HOURS. We’d been coming here for years, ever since I’d taken Oliver back as a client, for the third time. I decided some people were worth the headache.
“Breakfast for dinner?” Oliver asked.
“Always,” I smiled.
We sat in the truck, parked for a moment, neither of us moving to get out.
Oliver was humming.
“Emma’s song?” I asked quietly.
“Always,” he said. “It’s always for Emma.”
Inside, we both ordered pancakes and coffee. We talked about Oliver’s deck that still needed fixing. And, of course, the beer I still owed him. “And my Cardinals, Thomas? We’ve lost almost every game.”
The normal things. These are the things you talk about when someone almost took something from you, but didn’t.
Outside, the sky was now dark, the streetlights on. And somewhere in town, a person who’d made a phone call was going about their evening, maybe satisfied, maybe disappointed.
We’d probably never know who it was. Or why.
But Oliver was sitting across from me, eating pancakes, humming his daughter’s song between bites.
And tonight? That was enough.
Some Thursdays steal everything from you. Some Saturdays try to take what’s left.
But sometimes, if you’re lucky, someone’s paying attention.
And the truth is enough to bring you home.
“Thomas, I’ve been thinking about the blue Civic all night. And that name. Patricia Denton.”
“What about her?” I was half-awake. The call came in at 3:19 AM, Oliver’s name flashing on the screen.
“She was there! On Thursday. My Thursday. The white sedan that pulled up after… after everything happened. She’s the one who got out. She stood there. Just watching while they…” His voice cracked. “She never lifted a finger. Never tried to help. Didn’t even call 911. She just watched.”
I was fully awake now. “Oliver.”
“What if she’s been watching ever since, Thomas?”
5 Minute Observations 
Leave a comment